Domestic variety shows will always open my eyes.
A case-solving variety show, what rushed into the hot search was not how delicate the script was, how brain-burning the puzzle was, but…
Guests disagree.
In this scene, some people said that Ying bullied Yang Zi in the workplace, and some people said that he didn’t kick the show to hype the sad-fishing.
Star relationships and discord are difficult for spectators to understand, but the quality of a program is not up to standard, and the audience can see at a glance.
"Detective Moe"This variety show that opened under the wilderness once gave me the urge to think of cos emojis:
Why can’t I control these hands?
If this point had come out earlier, I wouldn’t have clicked on it
Before watching the feature film, I actually had a lot of expectations for Moe Tan.
After all, this so-called first IP immersive reasoning reality show in the country, the guest lineup invited is really good:
Two veteran celebrities were in charge, two male and female traffic escorts, plus Sha Yi Yang Di’s two comedians were joking, and one was busy with idols to adjust the atmosphere. They had everything they should have.
However, after watching a few issues, I just want to sigh, success or failure.
Let’s start with the most obvious comparison.
The third issue, the theme of "Celebration of the Year".
All the members traveled to the play "Qing Yu Nian", Sun Honglei transformed into Chen Pingping, Na Ying played the eldest princess, the third prince of Huang Zitao, Yang Zi Fan Ruoruo, Yang Di became Fan Sizhe, Sha Yi was Fei Jie, and an extra third son of the Fan family, Song Yaxuan "Fan Ersai".
Also invited the original drama true male and female protagonists, Zhang Ruoyun and Li Qin, once again played Fan Xian and Lin Waner.
All of them received the same mission: there is enough poisoned wine in the mother-in-law pot to poison the second prince, and they can choose whether to toast ordinary wine or poisoned wine.
In other words, everyone has the opportunity to commit a crime, and everyone can be a murderer.
After the Second Prince died,The investigation has officially begun…
Everyone takes turns to point out the object of their suspicion and the reasons, and respond to their own doubts.
For example, the first person to be caught in the fire was the third prince Huang Zitao. During the chaotic banquet toast, his strange behavior such as robbing other people’s clothes, talking harshly to Yang Zi, and secretly pouring out the wine aroused everyone’s suspicion.
And Huang Zitao himself, who was "besieged"?
The explanation is also rather weak, and he can only prove his innocence by swearing and wanting to quit the show.
Zhang Ruoyun still couldn’t stand it, so he took the initiative to stand up and help him share part of the war.
First, he analyzed the situation on the field, pointing out that Song Yaxuan stepped on Huang Zitao the first time he spoke, and guided everyone to follow the trend and suspect Huang, which was a very wrong behavior.
Now the reasoning has just begun, and there is no clue at all. Why did you bite someone to death so firmly? Is it taking a rhythm?
The suspect himself, who was rescued from the fire and water, would only applaud from the side at this time:
Then, Zhang Ruoyun questioned the cause of the second prince’s death: Was the poisoned wine at the scene necessarily poisoned to death? Could there be other modus operandi?
He even directly "jumped" the murderer card and was the first to admit that he had poisoned.
But he also suggested that he would definitely not be the only one. There must be others who have poisoned. Who is the real murderer who really killed, and we have to continue to dig deeper.
This flow of clouds and water, at a glance, is a high-level role play tabletop game player, to several other newcomers to say a stupefied.
The first wave of centralized reasoning did not produce any results, but it was a good start.
There is still a plot to follow.
Everyone went to Niulan Street to avoid Guo Baokun and Cheng Jushu and protect the token.
This part is like the detectiveIt doesn’t matter.Now.
It is purely a funny plot specially arranged to create some variety show jokes. Watching male stars dress up as women, female stars drill at the bottom of the table, just to increase their ears.
The so-called arrest is also rather careless.
The token that they were required to protect in the rules would not only be easily handed over to others, but they could even lose it while walking.
In the end, he was not eliminated because anyone’s token was gone.
So what is the significance of this token grab? I don’t know.
After that, he changed the scene again and really entered the stage of finding clues to solve the case.
The most important clue:The second prince did not die from poison, because his constitution was invulnerable to poison.
The program team arranged for the NPC to inform them directly.
No gaming experience at all.
Later, it was discovered that the second prince was killed by a robot from the temple. The reasoning process was simplified from finding the modus operandi to finding who matched the characteristics of the robot.
After seeing this, I was still convinced that it would be much easier.
As a result, this period of concentrated reasoning has turned into an extremely chaotic"Bite"…
At first, Li Qin suspected Huang Zitao, and the reasons he gave were reasonable:
Later, Sun Honglei and others suddenly bit Zhang Ruoyun, which is pure "idealism".
It was that he had a different personality from life, and it was strange that his hood had fallen off, and that he was laughing wrong.
The change in tone was so fast that Zhang Ruoyun and the later stage were stunned.
Zhang Ruoyun tried several times to bring the situation back to analyzing the clues, emphasizing that off-site information has nothing to do with solving the case.There is evidence to see the evidence…
It was rejected by Huang Zitao.
"We have no evidence."
Good guy, this is the first time I’ve seen a detective variety show without looking at the evidence.
Even his previous idea that the second prince might not have been poisoned to death by poisoned wine was taken as one of the evidence for the murderer.
Zhang Ruoyun did not expect that his logic and rigorous thinking were a little more careful, but instead he set himself on fire.
Life is lovely.jpg
In the end, he was forced to the point where there was really nothing he could do, so he persuaded:
Still useless.
Yang Di’s words revealed the essence of this farce:
Not ashamed, but proud.
There are so many domestic garbage variety shows, and there is a reason to be especially disappointed with "Moe Detective".
No matter from the production or the lineup, this show has taken a lot of effort.
The passage of a popular domestic script in each issue, from costume props to scene reconstruction, all cost money.
"Lurking" invited Li Chengru, Zhu Shimao, Yao Anlian and many other veteran celebrities;
In addition to the male and female protagonists of "Qingyu Nian", the second prince, Eunuch Hou, Cheng Jushu, and He Daoren are also the original actors;
"Huanzhu Gege" also invited Zhang Tielin, Dai Chunrong, Wang Yan, Zeng Li and others.
Who saw it without sighing a big deal!
Even the meaningless hide-and-seek on Niulan Street mentioned earlier also invited many extras to wear ancient costumes and forcefully created a real ancient market.
More attentive than many small-budget costume dramas.
However, the more attentive the production of the program and the guest lineup, the more it reflects their reasoning and solves the casenot attentive–
Sun Honglei still continues the image in "Extreme Challenge", with a simple mind, robbing people when they see him.
Huang Zitao’s "not in the service area" thinking is also very maverick.
In the final stage of reasoning, the reason for voting for Sha Yi was that the color of the paintings hanging on the wall was similar to Sha Yi’s clothes.
That Ying was very emotional, insisting that Yang Zi was still deceived by Yang Zi in the last issue.
Sha Yi is even more pitiful. In various variety shows, he is always a "unlucky guy" character, either being dumped or on the way to be dumped.
These celebrities who have been in the entertainment industry for many years really can’t understand the rules of the game and don’t know how to solve the case based on evidence clues?
Not necessarily.
When the supporting cast of the first issue of "Hidden" appeared, he recognized the other party in a second. When he got serious, he was not "simple-minded" at all, and the tears when he was emotional were sincere and touching.
In the small test before the recording of the program, in order to help Na Ying complete the task, Huang Zitao designed the routine Sun Honglei’s thinking was also very clear, and everyone believed in the acting.
Why did everyone start thinking about short-circuiting their IQ offline as soon as the reasoning investigation officially started?
Perhaps there is only one explanation:
In variety shows, many celebrities are deliberately "pretending to be stupid".
This problem is not limited to "Moe Detective".
We see stars in many different types of showsbrainless hypothesisThe atmosphere gradually prevailed.
For example, Bao Wenjing said that he doesn’t know how to count within 10:
Cheng Yi ran on the boy, playing the game so slow that his teammates were puzzled:
Zhang Yujian is always in a mysterious state outside the show, and the other guests can’t stand it:
Wu Xuanyi’s subjects were tested six times, and he said that he had been hit by a car for five or six meters. His lack of common sense was complained by the audience, and Weibo complained and commented on the rollover…
Many of the confused words and deeds in the eyes of ordinary people are just the dedication of brothers and sisters to the variety show effect in the eyes of fans, and it doesn’t hurt.
Fans didn’t care. Celebrities refused to show their intelligence on the show, but they could understand a thing or two.
You see "Ming Zhan", Yang Rong and Liu Haoran play very seriously every time, there are bullet comments that they are too serious; "Extreme Challenge" Huang Lei "old fox" character set up, whatever you do will be interpreted by various kinds.
Why don’t some people reason well?
Because when every move may be amplified at any time, there seems to be an additional "unspoken rule":Seriously, you lose.
And "selling stupidity" is always easier and safer than using your brain.
Establishing a silly white and sweet character for yourself, from a certain perspective, is actually a"Self-insurance" optionWhat is it?
He chose brainlessness, gave up shrewdness, hid in safety, and avoided speculation.
What’s more, "Moe Detective" itself does not have the biggest goal of solving the case. In the pilot film, a small clue test, five of the six guests failed the challenge, and the director only said one sentence:
"I’m going to change the program mode."
Other reasoning programs, such as "The Great Escape", "Ming Zhan", "The Prisoner Is You", etc., focus most of their content on searching for clues, reasoning ideas, and analyzing the real murderer.
If the case is difficult and the group is stuck, it is also possible to record from dawn to dark, how can all the key clues be delivered to the door by the NPC for nothing?
Compared with the same type of variety show, "Moe Tan" is more like sailing under false colors.
In order to quickly create topics, get ratings, click, do not patiently polish the script, study the process of solving the case, but focus on forcibly piling up people, making jokes, in the name of investigating the case, line funny, act cute, really put the cart before the horse.
Or do they really think it’s more friendly to the audience?
Perhaps many domestic variety shows have forgotten one thing:
For the audience, artificially created jokes are just a glimpse of the surface, and what can really make people clap the table and scream at the second brush and the third brush is always the spark of brain collision, the flash that is finally captured by hard thinking, and the emotion when immersed in digging the answer.
A reasoning variety show, inviting a group of big names, was finally resolved by such low-intelligence entertainment.
Isn’t that a pity?
